Addressing the Increased Frequency of Scholarship Awards Being Returned
I have the sense I am not the only one experiencing unique issues related to scholarship awards this year.
In recent weeks, I have received several more scholarship award checks kicked back to us – students are still in school and continuing, but these outside scholarship awards they have earned are not being applied. Whatever the shift has been in how institutions are now doing and applying financial aid (grants, internal scholarship, etc.) it’s creating an issue and the dollars awarded on behalf of the student are not being applied.
The one I was notified of in the last few days is for a student on a renewing scholarship who has received it and had it applied just fine for the past three years – she is now a senior at Notre Dame, and they’re apparently kicking back the $1,000 scholarship award to us. They are stating that if they accept the scholarship it will reduce her university aid dollar for dollar and that she received “more aid” this year (and in my mind, I don’t know why they wouldn’t do that and then apply those dollars to another student who has need). The student emailed me a copy of the letter they sent her, dated October 1st – we have not yet received the letter or check in our office. She’ll essentially be out her scholarship if they will not apply it – she can’t be given it directly.
The letter we send with the award check to the institution is like many others – it states:
“This scholarship may be used in the fall 2026 semester for any tuition, lab fees, books, and any other education related expenses incurred by (the student). If any money remains, it may be applied to the spring 2027 semester tuition. After the spring 2027 semester if any funds remain, we ask you to return the remaining balance to the Heart of Illinois Community Foundation, and not to the student.”
I wonder if we’re going to collectively have to determine how to word or instruct the award letters to ensure they are applied as warranted – these students earned the awards and donors would like to see them awarded. Do we now have a conflict between how aid is applied and the laws under which we also operate with scholarships? I don’t know what this is going to mean or look like going forward, but as we are already preparing the next cycle for the next academic year, I’m sure I am not alone in wanting to be ahead of this (for our collective sanity – no one has time to be doing all of the additional reissuing of awards and tracking, just to have it all sent back again).
I’m wondering how everyone is navigating this currently, what issues are they experiencing, and if we need to lead a conversation between scholarship providers and the institutions so we can each proceed forward together and appropriately support students. Also, can anyone recommend other resources that can help us navigate this new season we’re in?
Thank you in advance for your input!
Andrea Gerhard
Comments
-
It would be strange for the student to all of a sudden have an over award issue, especially since the cost just keeps going up. Maybe the student had some other aid increase. You could call ND and ask. I've talked to many financial aid officers to get an idea of how our scholarship would be treated and learned a lot.
We started collecting student financial aid awards from students as part of our application process. We want our awards used, too, but not to replace the institutional aid and then essentially diverted to another student that is not from our area. We don't have this perfected, or course, because other people are awarding when we are, but it's a start. We take it into consideration when choosing recipients. It also makes those phone calls with financial aid easier. I already know some things that they can't tell me.
1 -
Thanks for the input @MollyCerroni - I agree, this is strange. I did also call Notre Dame already. It was also a strange conversation, as they referred to the award letter as "the restrictions included with the award" - the letter has been the same all four years with how to apply it. The student had reached out initially when she received a copy of the letter from the school (we still have not received it or the returned check in office). The student indicated she does indeed have other educational expenses related to books and fees, but the financial aid office stated "it's covered". I encouraged the student to go to have a conversation with them to try to figure it out.
This case is a renewing scholarship which the student has been awarded for three years with no issue until now. I have had other scholarship awards kicked back for some first time recipients this fall as well - there's a clear shift in how things are being applied (or not), and now having to carry those awards over to next fall means additional tracking and hoping that we'll not have the same issue next year.
1 -
I hope the student lets you know the outcome, it sure would help you to know what happened.
Maybe her SAI went up? Another scholarship? Graduating early?
There was some talk of an over award for a student causing a PELL grant cancellation back in March or so. I asked some financial aid personnel earlier this year but they didn't know how that would play out. It seems to have disappeared because when I google it, I can't find the policy.
Every year it changes.
2 -
@AndreaGerhard Could it possibly be related to the changes in ND's tuition policy that went into effect this year and how they are applying aid?
1 -
@SarahBurzycki in this particular case, it's the most likely reason except the student is indicating there are things related to her education that still are not covered (and having her award applied would help that). In the letter they sent they refer to our letter as having "terms and restrictions" (though it says
any tuition, lab fees, books, and any other education related expenses incurred by (the student)and it's applicable to fall and spring semester). The wording they now use in their letter says "Notre Dame meets the demonstrated financial need of each student without loans. Under our University outside scholarship policy, external awards are first used to reduce any work in the aid offer. Since [the student's] aid offer does not include work, accepting this check would require a dollar-for-dollar reduction of our University need-based scholarship. Therefore, we are returning the $1,000 check." The student has received this scholarship the past three years (so it's arrival was to be expected). I think to be further proactive I'll have to reinforce to students the importance of early reporting to their financial aid offices. I wish there was a centralized location we could view and understand the policies of each university to help anticipate ahead of time where the issues might bubble up. We're at a standstill for this particular student, but hopefully the others experiencing issues will be able to be worked out before next fall.1



