Evaluating / Reviewing the Scholarship Process
Hi All!
Now that the scholarship process is over (mostly - still waiting on some students to complete their scholarship acceptance forms), I want to do an evaluation or review of the process from various perspectives. I'd like to put together some surveys to ask at least 4 groups of users how they found the system to work for them and what tweaks we could do (maybe) to make it better for them.
Student Applicant (including those who started but did not submit applications)
Evaluators (board/staff evaluators)
Letter writers who uploaded letters of recommendations (or not)
Guidance Counselors who got emails to upload transcripts
Now - that I said that the professional way - I know I'm not going to be able to help the ones that don't read the instructions I already have (but in some cases I recognize I could have better instructions they won't read)
And I can't help the ones who start the application process an hour or so before the deadline.
Or the ones that just are too unmotivated to complete their application.
That said - this being the first year that we went online with the SLM, and the Universal Application, I know there were some students (and parents) who didn't understand that they needed to complete that application process to get to the selection of scholarships for which they would be eligible.
So if you have any surveys you've used with your SLM users, would you be willing to share?
And would you be willing to share any particular reports you've run to provide statistics to your scholarship committee or board to show the effectiveness of the process? (I know my committees loved the scholarship evaluation summary reports I ran before our meetings! That made the review process so much easier!
Thanks for your help on the eve of a three-day weekend.
Happy Independence Day!
Bettie
Bettie Stammerjohn
Executive Director
Community Foundation of Greene County, Pennsylvania
Comments
-
Hi Bettie,
It sounds like you had quite the year of transition for your scholarships! We don't have a survey at this time, but reading through your question posed here I thought of some ideas for you.
For the students who applied for the scholarship, here are some question ideas:
- Was this the only scholarship application you completed online? Yes/no.
- Did the application process take less time than expected, about the time expected, or much more time than expected? Or, you could even add, how long did the application take you to complete?
- Which part of the application was easiest to understand, and which were you the most unsure about?
- For those who did not complete an application (and not those who started it an hour before or etc.), you can ask why didn't you complete your application?
I hope you get other good answers here. I am curious to see what others have to say about this.
Take care,
Danielle
7 -
Hi Danielle
Those are great questions.
I especially like the one about the time expected to complete.
I will also ask a question about the ease of using the online system and if the instructions were clear. (I have had some feedback in that area from a user.
I'll let you know how it goes!
Bettie
Bettie Stammerjohn
Executive Director
Community Foundation of Greene County, Pennsylvania
1 -
Hi Bettie! We are now in the same place you were with wanting to survey past applicants about our scholarship process. Were you able to put together a survey that you would be willing to share?
Thank you for any help you can provide!
Best,
Natalia
1 -
We never did get around to doing a survey of our recipients.
We used a feedback survey on the universal scholarship but I think we'll take it out.
Bettie Stammerjohn
Executive Director
Community Foundation of Greene County, Pennsylvania
1